• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Transform Scotland

Transform Scotland

  • About Us
        • Our team
        • Our members
        • Contact us
        • About us

  • Our Priorities
        • Safe places for active travel
        • Zero-carbon connectivity
        • Zero-carbon public transport
        • Zero-carbon investment
        • Fair transport pricing
        • Our priorties

  • Our Work
        • Publications
        • Our projects
        • #lovemybus
        • Consultancy
        • Cross-Party Group
        • Our work

  • Latest
        • News
        • Alerts
        • Events
        • Latest

  • Join us
  • Donate

STPR2: Lack of traffic demand management spoils transport infrastructure strategy

13 April 2022

by Transform Scotland

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Traffic queue by steadyrollin’ on Flickr (CC BY-NC 2.0)

Transform Scotland has today published its response to the Scottish Government’s Strategic Transport Projects Review (STPR2).

The proposals have much to welcome, with a welcome set of proposals for investment in active travel; expanded mass transit networks in Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Glasgow; and a shift from new road-building to road maintenance, as a response to the climate crisis and to improve the climate resilence of transport networks.

However, Transform is sceptical that the proposals have sufficient urgency in implementation, and that they contain the measures which will meet the Government’s 20% traffic reduction target.

Transform director Colin Howden said:

“STPR2 includes not only infrastructure investment priorities but also seeks to influence travel choice and behaviour. But behaviour change measures to encourage the switch to public transport will fail if not accompanied by price signals which incentivise public transport use and disincentivise excessive levels of car use. In essence, it is of little use encouraging people to use public transport if it remains unaffordable compared to car use — and decades of price data demonstrate that public transport has become progressively less affordable compared to the car. The failure to set out any road traffic demand management measures is the critical failure within STPR2. It also puts the credibility of the Scottish Government’s target to reduce car kilometres by 20% by 2030 into question.”

On the infrastructure priorities set out in STPR2, Howden said:

“We welcome that active travel infrastructure is recognised as strategic to the transport network. There are welcome proposals on bus prioritisation, and we agree with many of the priorities laid out for inter-city rail and moving more freight to rail.

“It’s in the area of roads policy where STPR2 changes most from previous years’ infrastructure priorities. While 2008’s STPR1 led to a multi-billion pound road-building programme which directly damaged the prospects of Scotland meeting its legally-binding climate targets, STPR2 largely focuses on maintaining and enhancing the existing road network.

“However, it looks like the dinosaur road-builders at Transport Scotland plan to make their final stand in the Western Isles, where they propose a series of inter-island tunnels. These proposals are preposterous. The schemes would have vast project costs — we would estimate several billions of pounds — and risibly poor cost-benefit scores. Furthermore, precisely no information is presented on the environmental consequences of such schemes, let alone the climate implications involved in their construction, and as such we are not confident that their environmental impact would not be catastrophic in extent. There are ample other opportunities for investment in the infrastructure in the Islands which would be of greater value; in the area of transport, measures to tackle the negative unintended consequences of the rapid expansion of car-based tourism in these areas would be of greater value. As such, pursuing tunnels and/or bridges at excessive cost would inevitably entail a vast opportunity cost for more appropriate targets for investment.”

Downloads

Transform Scotland response

External Links

Transport Scotland consultation

Featured NewsRoads Traffic

Share

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Back to Latest

Latest posts

Our work over the past 12 months | 2023 Annual Report published

20 September 2023

We’ve today published our new Annual Report, which reflects on our work and activities for the year 2022/23. In the midst of a cost-of-living crisis and the ongoing climate emergency…

Read more

Featured NewsPublic transport Traffic

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry: Lessons learned

19 September 2023

The long-awaited inquiry into the the delays and costs of the first phase of the Edinburgh Tram project has today been published. The inquiry scrutinised the reasons for the project…

Read more

NewsPublic transport

Fair Fares? An opportunity for innovative policymaking

12 September 2023

Transform policy advisor Tom Flanagan reports on the Government’s progress in delivering its commitments to improve the affordability and accessibility of public transport through fares.

Read more

Featured NewsPolicy Public transport

Join our team as a communications assistant

11 September 2023

We are looking for a Communications Assistant to join our team! This is a voluntary role and would require a commitment of approx. 3-7 hours per week. Main duties include:…

Read more

News

Sign up for email updates

We'll send you news on our work, plus other updates about how you can get involved in Scotland's campaign for sustainable transport.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Cookies policy
  • Credits
  • Accessibility
  • Work for us
  • Leave a legacy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

© 2023 Transform Scotland is a registered Scottish charity (SC041516)


Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!