• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Transform Scotland

Transform Scotland

  • About Us
        • Our team
        • Our members
        • Contact us
        • About us

  • Our Work
        • Publications
        • Our projects
        • Consultancy
        • Cross Party Group
        • Our work

  • Latest
        • News
        • Alerts
        • Events
        • Latest

  • Join us
  • Donate

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry: Lessons learned

19 September 2023

by Transform Scotland

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn

The long-awaited inquiry into the the delays and costs of the first phase of the Edinburgh Tram project has today been published.

The inquiry scrutinised the reasons for the project finishing five years later than expected – and at double the planned cost.

The 961-page report reveals and criticises various organisations whose acts and/or omissions contributed to the project overrunning in terms of schedule and budget.

The report is available here.

On the report, Transform Scotland policy advisor Nigel Bagshaw said:

“Lord Hardie’s report details clearly the already well-known problems which beset the first phase of the Edinburgh tram project: the incredible mismanagement of Transport Initiatives Edinburgh (TIE), the irreparably flawed nature of the infrastructure contract, the failure of Edinburgh Council officials to protect the council’s financial interests, and the strategic shortcomings of Scottish Ministers. None of the findings come as any surprise, but the report does provide a solid, even cathartic, record of what went wrong and sets out very valid recommendations.

“The errors of the original project have already been taken on board and avoided in the recent extension (completion) of the line from York Place to Newhaven and the inquiry report should be seen not as an argument against future lines in Edinburgh, or indeed other Scottish cites, but as a template for delivering them successfully as planned.”


Image courtesy of Edinburgh Trams

Transform Scotland played an important role in advocating for light rail to be added back into Scotland’s public transport mix, as well as keeping earlier phases of the Edinburgh trams project on course when various misguided political interests sought to cancel the scheme.

NewsPublic transport

Share

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Back to Latest

Latest posts

Cycling & Public Transport – Spokes Public Meeting

19 November

Read more

EventsActive Travel Public transport

Give Edinburgh’s bus-lane trial a fair chance

11 November 2026

Transform Scotland is urging Edinburgh councillors to allow the city’s 7-7-7 bus-lane trial to continue, with effective monitoring to assess its benefits and address any practical problems. In a written…

Read more

NewsPolicy Public transport Roads Traffic

Think Rail First: Transform & LNER Dundee Reception

10 November 2026

How can rail help drive sustainable tourism, strengthen local economies and improve community connectivity? LNER and Transform Scotland brought together senior leaders from Dundee and Tayside for a reception at…

Read more

Featured NewsClimate Investment Policy Public transport

Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network

5 November 2026

Transform Scotland has today published its briefing ahead of the Scottish Government’s ‘Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network’ debate in the Scottish Parliament. We welcome greater public accountability for bus services. But bus reform…

Read more

NewsPolicy Public transport Roads

Sign up for email updates

We'll send you news on our work, plus other updates about how you can get involved in Scotland's campaign for sustainable transport.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Cookies policy
  • Credits
  • Accessibility
  • Work for us
  • Leave a legacy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

© 2026 Transform Scotland is a registered Scottish charity (SC041516)