• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Transform Scotland

Transform Scotland

  • About Us
        • Our team
        • Our members
        • Contact us
        • About us

  • Our Work
        • Publications
        • Our projects
        • Consultancy
        • Cross Party Group
        • Our work

  • Latest
        • News
        • Alerts
        • Events
        • Latest

  • Join us
  • Donate

Failing on fairer transport: Our response to (another) UK budget fuel duty freeze

30 October 2024

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn

Director Colin Howden comments on today’s UK Budget, criticising Labour’s decision to maintain a subsidy for private car use – and the missed opportunity for progressive transport reforms.


Today’s UK Budget was truly dismal for those who had hoped that Labour would bring about a more progressive approach on transport taxation.

The decision to retain the previous administration’s fuel duty freeze further worsens the competitive position of public transport against car use. We’ve had fourteen years of this and yet Labour has decided to continue Tory policies which have literally driven people away from public transport and into private cars.

It would appear that UK Labour is interested in ‘working people’ who drive but not those who use public transport.

The government will protect working people and those in local communities by freezing fuel duty next year.

This is a tax cut worth £3bn and will save motorists almost £60 a year. pic.twitter.com/HhyvXYfI8L

— HM Treasury (@hmtreasury) October 30, 2024

Given the crass failure of leadership demonstrated by the UK Government on fuel duty, perhaps we should not be surprised to find that the Budget documents appear to continue no reference to the reform of motoring taxation –and, in particular, moves towards road pricing.

In the previous session of Parliament, the cross-party Westminster transport select committee demanded “radical reform” and concluded that “a failure to replace existing motoring taxes with an alternative road charging mechanism will lead to either decreased investment in public services, including road maintenance, or increased Government borrowing.” But here we are two years later, and the issue appears to have entirely evaporated from Labour’s plans.

The other note-worthy point is the additional £3.4bn Barnett Consequentials funding to Scotland, with the UK Chancellor indicating that this should be used to deliver improved public services in Scotland. Of course, these funds will be allotted to the Scottish Ministers to spend, so it remains to be seen whether any of the capital expenditure component (£610m) of this is invested in transport, and, if so, goes towards reinstating investment that it has cut in buses, walking and cycling over the past year, or is instead frittered away on the Scottish Government’s multi-billion pound road-building programme.

The Chancellor did announce some measures which will benefit transport in England, including some new rail links, an extra £500m for road maintenance, plus a reversal of the myopic decision by the previous administration to terminate HS2 miles short of a central London terminus. Its decision not to scrap the English bus fare cap has drawn positive reaction, but it still represents a 50% increase for bus passengers there at a time when car users are benefitting from a real terms cut in motoring costs.

At least the UK Government can at least be credited with movement on taxation on private jets, with a 50% increase in air passenger duty for those travelling on private jets, although I personally doubt that a £450 increase will dissuade Rishi Sunak (personal wealth c. £650,000,000) from his binge-flying.

BACK TO NEWS

Related articles/projects/publications

What is the top transport challenge for the new UK Government?

17 July 2024

Policy officer Laura Hyde-White comments on the recent UK general election, highlighting its impact on transport in Scotland. What does the new UK Government mean for Scottish transport? Transport is…

Read more

New report finds Scotland’s ‘Dirty Deals’ fuelling climate and poverty failures

19 March 2024

Scotland’s City Region Deals are fuelling inequality, damaging the environment and further undermining the country’s climate commitments, according to our new report ‘Dirty Deals’, published today.​ New data uncovered by…

Read more

What does the Scottish Budget mean for sustainable transport?

27 February 2024

The Scottish Budget process draws to a close this afternoon, and it’s a real mixed bag for sustainable transport.

Read more

Evidence to the UK Parliament Transport Committee on zero emissions vehicles and road pricing

17 February 2021

Transform submitted evidence to the UK Parliament Transport Committee on zero emissions vehicles and road pricing.

Download now

NewsAviation Cars Equalities Policy Public transport

Share

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Back to Latest

Latest posts

Cycling & Public Transport – Spokes Public Meeting

19 November

Read more

EventsActive Travel Public transport

Give Edinburgh’s bus-lane trial a fair chance

11 November 2026

Transform Scotland is urging Edinburgh councillors to allow the city’s 7-7-7 bus-lane trial to continue, with effective monitoring to assess its benefits and address any practical problems. In a written…

Read more

NewsPolicy Public transport Roads Traffic

Think Rail First: Transform & LNER Dundee Reception

10 November 2026

How can rail help drive sustainable tourism, strengthen local economies and improve community connectivity? LNER and Transform Scotland brought together senior leaders from Dundee and Tayside for a reception at…

Read more

Featured NewsClimate Investment Policy Public transport

Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network

5 November 2026

Transform Scotland has today published its briefing ahead of the Scottish Government’s ‘Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network’ debate in the Scottish Parliament. We welcome greater public accountability for bus services. But bus reform…

Read more

NewsPolicy Public transport Roads

Sign up for email updates

We'll send you news on our work, plus other updates about how you can get involved in Scotland's campaign for sustainable transport.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Cookies policy
  • Credits
  • Accessibility
  • Work for us
  • Leave a legacy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

© 2026 Transform Scotland is a registered Scottish charity (SC041516)