• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Transform Scotland

Transform Scotland

  • About Us
        • Our team
        • Our members
        • Contact us
        • About us

  • Our Priorities
        • Safe places for active travel
        • Zero-carbon connectivity
        • Zero-carbon public transport
        • Zero-carbon investment
        • Fair transport pricing
        • Our priorties

  • Our Work
        • Publications
        • Our projects
        • #lovemybus
        • Consultancy
        • Cross-Party Group
        • Our work

  • Latest
        • News
        • Alerts
        • Events
        • Latest

  • Join us
  • Donate

TRO Review “fails the test of transparency”

29 July 2021

by Transform Scotland

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Photo by Ben Wicks on Unsplash

We have responded to Transport Scotland’s ‘Traffic Regulation Order Review Consultation‘. In our response, we call for a more fundamental review of the TRO process, arguing that the current process is not understandable beyond a narrow field of specialists within Local Authorities.

Transform director Colin Howden said:

“In his Ministerial Foreword to the consultation, Graeme Dey says that it is important that ‘the views of the public are put at the heart of this review’. But we’re certain that the current system will remain a complete mystery until a more fundamental review of the TRO process is carried out. Unfortunately, this consultation is framed in the context of concerns raised by Local Authorities with background documents prepared as though the objective of the exercise is only to mitigate the problems faced by Local Authorities.

“The consultation notes the welter of different TROs and other orders, procedures, and requirements. This might be understood by professional Local Authority staff, but is no doubt highly confusing to local residents and anyone else with an interest in the outcome the orders are intended to produce. It therefore fails the test of transparency.

“In our response we have suggested a new set of principles which would provide a more useful way in which to base the system in future.”

Transform has proposed that the following be used as the basis for a new TRO system:

  • Emergency orders: generally covering hours or days, at most a few weeks, when an unpredicted event occurs such as a road collapse, or ‘major incident’. Inherently, consultation is not practicable. However, notification of those affected should take place as soon as possible.
  • Short-term orders: covering a limited period, to accommodate predicted events such as planned road works, building works or local events. This could include situations such as those described in the background papers as ‘experimental’; such as Spaces for People or any other measure where a ‘try and modify’ approach is appropriate.
  • Permanent orders: probably covering all other situations. This could include ‘Redetermination Orders’. However, within this group a mechanism is needed to cover minor variations e.g. slightly extending a parking bay or double yellow line (e.g. by a metre or so), which appear currently to require the full TRO process, which is obviously disproportionate.

Downloads

Transform consultation response

External Links

Transport Scotland consultation

Featured NewsCars Traffic

Share

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Back to Latest

Latest posts

Our work over the past 12 months | 2023 Annual Report published

20 September 2023

We’ve today published our new Annual Report, which reflects on our work and activities for the year 2022/23. In the midst of a cost-of-living crisis and the ongoing climate emergency…

Read more

Featured NewsPublic transport Traffic

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry: Lessons learned

19 September 2023

The long-awaited inquiry into the the delays and costs of the first phase of the Edinburgh Tram project has today been published. The inquiry scrutinised the reasons for the project…

Read more

NewsPublic transport

Fair Fares? An opportunity for innovative policymaking

12 September 2023

Transform policy advisor Tom Flanagan reports on the Government’s progress in delivering its commitments to improve the affordability and accessibility of public transport through fares.

Read more

Featured NewsPolicy Public transport

Join our team as a communications assistant

11 September 2023

We are looking for a Communications Assistant to join our team! This is a voluntary role and would require a commitment of approx. 3-7 hours per week. Main duties include:…

Read more

News

Sign up for email updates

We'll send you news on our work, plus other updates about how you can get involved in Scotland's campaign for sustainable transport.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Cookies policy
  • Credits
  • Accessibility
  • Work for us
  • Leave a legacy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

© 2023 Transform Scotland is a registered Scottish charity (SC041516)


Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!