• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Transform Scotland

Transform Scotland

  • About Us
        • Our team
        • Our members
        • Contact us
        • About us

  • Our Priorities
        • Safe places for active travel
        • Zero-carbon connectivity
        • Zero-carbon public transport
        • Zero-carbon investment
        • Fair transport pricing
        • Our priorties

  • Our Work
        • Publications
        • Our projects
        • #lovemybus
        • Consultancy
        • Cross-Party Group
        • Our work

  • Latest
        • News
        • Alerts
        • Events
        • Latest

  • Join us
  • Donate

NTS2 Delivery Plan falls short of ambition to protect rights of individuals & advance equality of opportunity

6 January 2022

by Transform Scotland

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Photo by Ross Sneddon on Unsplash

Transform has published its response to Transport Scotland’s impact assessment of its National Transport Strategy Delivery Plan, noting that the timing of this to be “unusual and unfortunate”, and raising concern regarding the absence of a Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) of the Plan.

We welcome the human rights approach embodied in the document, and fully support the stated commitment to adopt a legal framework that protects the rights of individuals and advances equality of opportunity. However, “we feel that the NTS2 Delivery Plan falls somewhat short of that ambition. Transport policy and proposed delivery in Scotland remains significantly skewed towards those that have wealth, assets and an existing high quality of mobility. The balance of spend, both through capital investment and revenue support, while paying lip service to the hierarchy of investment remains stubbornly fixated on a high carbon and largely exclusive transport system. This needs to change if Transport Scotland is to become an active agent for a just transition.”

Our response states that“The point of impact assessments, particularly on those groups with protected characteristics, is to inform policy development and correct any undue bias or inadvertent discrimination before adoption of the policy. To undertake impact assessments after adoption and publication of the policy or plan is a missed opportunity and could lead to the acceptance of a flawed approach or policy in practice when earlier efforts to undertake the impact assessments would have resulted in a more considered understanding of the likely impacts.” Impact assessments should instead be carried out before, or at least in parallel with, the development of policies and plans.

With regard to SEA, Transform’s response “consider[s] it an imperative that all strategic transport policies and interventions now require an SEA and would encourage Transport Scotland to undertake one either in retrospect (as per the current impact assessments) or certainly at the next iteration of the Delivery Plan.”

Our response goes on to consider climate change, air pollution, and the affordability, accessibility and availability of public transport. It makes a number of practical suggestions for action, including:

  • That every local authority should be encouraged to adopt mobility share schemes that cater for a range of incomes and cycling abilities which do not depend on the ability to pay.
  • The widespread adoption of a uniform and consistent modelling tool such as SCATTER, with specific proposals to reduce carbon inequalities in transport provision.
  • The Scottish Government to bring its pollution limits in line with the World Health Organization, following the dramatic world-first coroner’s ruling that the death of 9-year-old, Ella Kissi-Debrah, was caused by air pollution.
  • The acceleration of efforts to decarbonise all modes of travel including bus, rail, ferry and air travel, with clear action plans, and target dates accelerated for the decarbonisation of each mode.
  • Whilst commending the Scottish Government’s decision to introduce free bus travel for the under-22s, for it to also consider wider application of free public transport schemes in certain circumstances, in particular linked to poverty allieviation interventions.
  • The introduction of a national smart ticketing system available to all, building on the success of the multi-modal transport passes issued to COP26 delegates.
  • The establishment of a ‘Fair Transport Commission’ to build on the work of the Fair Work Commissions around the country and working with the proposed Future of Transport Forum. One of the key tasks of the Fair Transport Commission and the Future of Transport Forum would be to set minimum standards for the availability of transport to all communities across the country.

Downloads

Transform response

External Links

Transport Scotland consultation

Featured News

Share

FacebookTweetEmailLinkedIn
Back to Latest

Latest posts

Our work over the past 12 months | 2023 Annual Report published

20 September 2023

We’ve today published our new Annual Report, which reflects on our work and activities for the year 2022/23. In the midst of a cost-of-living crisis and the ongoing climate emergency…

Read more

Featured NewsPublic transport Traffic

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry: Lessons learned

19 September 2023

The long-awaited inquiry into the the delays and costs of the first phase of the Edinburgh Tram project has today been published. The inquiry scrutinised the reasons for the project…

Read more

NewsPublic transport

Fair Fares? An opportunity for innovative policymaking

12 September 2023

Transform policy advisor Tom Flanagan reports on the Government’s progress in delivering its commitments to improve the affordability and accessibility of public transport through fares.

Read more

Featured NewsPolicy Public transport

Join our team as a communications assistant

11 September 2023

We are looking for a Communications Assistant to join our team! This is a voluntary role and would require a commitment of approx. 3-7 hours per week. Main duties include:…

Read more

News

Sign up for email updates

We'll send you news on our work, plus other updates about how you can get involved in Scotland's campaign for sustainable transport.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Cookies policy
  • Credits
  • Accessibility
  • Work for us
  • Leave a legacy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn

© 2023 Transform Scotland is a registered Scottish charity (SC041516)


Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!